Picture Book Review: Candy Corn Christmas by Jonathan Fenske

Candy Corn Christmas
Author: Jonathan Fenske
Illustrator: Jonathan Fenske
Little Simon
9 September 2025
40 pages

This month’s PB review is by Ryan G. Van Cleave (Owner/​Operator of Only Picture Books) and freelance illustrator Edna Cabcabin Moran.

Ryan’s Review of the Writing

Candy Corn Christmas! has a playful premise: the candy corn left behind after Halloween get tired of waiting in their pumpkin pail and wander straight into Christmas. That jump is the book’s best move. The candy corn feel like kids discovering a holiday for the first time, bouncing from tree to stockings to eggnog with total confidence and zero understanding of boundaries. That sense of mischief gives the book oomph. The pacing stays quick, almost episodic, which works well for a story built on discovery—it keeps kids moving right along with the candy corn.

The art does most of the heavy lifting, and Fenske’s illustrations are lively and fun. The spreads are busy in the best way, full of tiny jokes and expressive candy faces that kids will spot right away. When the candy corn zip across ornaments or dunk themselves in nog, the pages pop. I’ll let Edna talk far more concretely about the art, but to my eye? The whole visual world feels loose, bright, and energetic. There’s also an easy, chatty confidence to the narration that helps the candy corn feel like a little chorus of eager kids, which gives the book a friendly, accessible voice from page one.

The emotional moment arrives when a candy cane tries to shove them back to “their” holiday. It’s clear, simple conflict that sets up Santa’s entrance. Santa’s brief mix-​up and quick course-​correct land well, and the ending settles into a cheerful, everyone-​belongs kind of holiday note without overworking the message. Kids will instantly recognize the moment when someone says, “You don’t belong here,” so the book’s turn toward welcome lands in a way little readers can feel even before the text explains it.

The book’s rhyme has enthusiasm, and Fenske hits those end rhymes with confidence. The rhythm getting there wobbles now and then, though, in a way adults will hear but still remain fun for kids. It’s charming in its own loose, bouncy way even if the scansion isn’t fully locked in.

Overall, the idea is cute, the art is genuinely fun, and kids will enjoy the candy-​corn-​chaos of it all. The visuals and the concept pull readers through with plenty of good-​natured holiday energy.

4 out of 5 candy corns


Edna’s Review of the Illustrations

As someone who isn’t a fan of the orange, yellow, and white-​striped confections, I found myself completely won over by a charming throng of candy corn creatures. These rollicking fellows with their antics and liveliness greatly enhance Jonathan Fenske’s rhyming picture book, Candy Corn Christmas. Illustrations tinged with subversive humor pulled this reader into a sharply-​drawn world and storyline that kept me at the edge of my seat.

Fenske’s line art candy corns are a standout in each cleanly-​rendered, digitally-​painted page. The candy corns themselves are given active and expressive personalities which make them easy to follow. Candy corns all look alike, right? So, the artist did well to give these guys expressive faces and distinguishing features with different types of mouths and teeth, googly eyes with eyebrows and, in some cases, costume pieces. Look for the candy corn wearing the green elf hat and one donning a Canadian maple leaf flag.

The use of line art as a narrative device is a wise artist choice providing readers a chance to appreciate candy corns as individual characters. This is especially important given that the pace of the story moves so quickly that there’s a risk of noticing gags more than caring about the characters themselves. 

Line art highlights details such as candy corns feeling bored and stale around an old familiar pumpkin pail, and candy corns showing interest in the sound of singing and bells coming from another room. When the candy corns invade the Christmas confections’ space, Fenske’s use of line art successfully shows displeasure and worry emanating from the sugar plums, chocolate log, and candy cane.

**Spoiler alert in the next paragraph!**

Tensions rise when Santa shows up and he does the unthinkable, taking an actual bite (though it’s mentioned as a nibble) from a candy corn. The artist’s repetition of layout and close-​up action serves to increase story tension plus provide some comic relief. There’s Santa down on the ground examining the band of candy corns right before an extreme close up of Santa bringing a candy corn to his mouth. Then there’s another page showing Santa standing next to the candy corns (in the same line up as before) with one of them saying “My baby,” followed by a page showing a smiling, carefree Santa holding a traumatized, gooey candy corn in his palm. These pages will render this book less suitable for younger kids. While the graphic details surprised and cracked me up as an adult, I welcomed the relief of knowing that the candy corn did survive.

As mentioned earlier, this book contains both funny and subversive elements fueled by illustrations that will hold reader interest up to the very end. An entertaining book filled with details and visual intrigue for the older picture book set, pre‑K, and above.

4.5 out of 5 candy canes 

Edna Cabcabin Moran is an author/​illustrator, multi-​disciplined artist, and STEAM and integrative arts educator. Her latest picture book, Honu and Moa received an Aesop Accolades. Edna is currently working in picture books and comics and has a middle grade graphic novel in progress. Edna has a comic in the newly-​released middle grade anthology, Let’s Go!: A Kids Comics Studio Anthology. She is also a contributing poet in the upcoming March 2026 anthology, For the Win: Poems Celebrating Phenomenal Athletes (Carolrhoda Books).

https://kidlitedna.com

IG: @kidlitedna

Five-​Word Reviews: November Picks

Fresh releases, sharp impressions—five-word snapshots of picture books worth noticing.

Turns out, five words go a long way. I’ve done quite a few of these picture book speed-​dates this year, and they’re still one of the most-​requested features on the blog. No theme this time—just a fresh mix of the funny, strange, and beautifully told. Maybe one will follow you home.


And They Walk On
Author: Kevin Maillard
Illustrator: Rafael López
Roaring Brook Press
14 October 2025
4o pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Grief walks beside us, gently.

4.5 out of 5 memory seeds 🌱


Balloon
Author: Bruce Handy
Illustrator: Julie Kwon
Chronicle Books
14 October 2025
44 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Tender hearts float, then land.

4.5 out of 5 orange strings 🎈


Moon Song
Author: Michaela Goade
Illustrator: Michaela Goade
Little, Brown Books for Young Readers
7 October 2025
40 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Dark woods glow with wonder.

4.5 out of 5 moonlit paths 🌕


Seven Babies
Author: Forest Xiao
Illustrator: Forest Xiao
Candlewick
26 August 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Baby blitz. Love multiplies fast.

4.25 out of 5 bath splashes 🛁


Yellow Is a Banana
Author: John Himmelman
Illustrator: John Himmelman
Harry N. Abrams
7 October 2025
40 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Sibling logic spirals. Language mayhem.

4.25 out of 5 sibling standoffs 🧦

Picture Book Review: 5‑word reviews (The Cave Downwind of the Café, Hansel and Gretel, The Monster in the Lake, The Trouble with Giraffes, Unicorn Post)

There’s no grand theme this week. Just small jolts of delight, weirdness, and warmth. Each book gets five words—just enough to show why I might bring one (or all) to my picture book class for a closer look.


The Cave Downwind of the Café
Author: Mikey Please
Illustrator: Mikey Please
HarperCollins
9 September 2025
48 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Heroism served with snotty flair.

🥄4 out of 5 slime spoons


Hansel and Gretel
Author: Stephen King
Illustrator: Maurice Sendak
HarperCollins
2 September 2025
48 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Classic tale, sharpened into nightmare.

🔥 4.25 out of 5 witch’s ovens


The Monster in the Lake
Author: Leo Timmers
Illustrator: Leo Timmers
Gecko Press
9 September 2025
36 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Monster myths. One duck dares.

👀4 out of 5 surprising sightings


THE TROUBLE WITH GIRAFFESThe Trouble with Giraffes
Author: Lisa Mantchev
Illustrator: Taeeun Yoo
Simon & Schuster/​Paula Wiseman Books
16 September 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: True friends meet halfway, always.

💡 4.25 out of 5 clubhouse ideas


Unicorn Post
Author: Emma Yarlett
Illustrator: Emma Yarlett
Candlewick
26 August 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Whimsy and warmth, postage paid.

📬 4.25 out of 5 special deliveries

Picture Book Review: 5‑word reviews (Big Boy Joy; Diego Fuego; No More Chairs; Pencil’s Best Story Ever; To Catch a Ghost)

Each week, I sift through stacks of new picture books looking for the ones that feel fresh, moving, or just plain fun. These five-​word reviews are my way of marking what caught my eye and held it. Not full critiques, just honest first impressions drawn from voice, feeling, and the spark of something well made.

Let’s see which ones you remember.


Big Boy Joy
Author: Connie Schofield-​Morrison
Illustrator: Shamar Knight-​Justice
Bloomsbury Children’s Books
3 June 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Apologies build better playground days.

🏃‍♂️4.25 out of 5 soaring sneakers


Diego Fuego: The Firefighting Dragon
Author: Allison Rozo and Rafael Rozo
Illustrator: Vanessa Morales
Penguin Workshop
22 July 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Fireproof charm. Frozen flair. Familia.

🔥🚫 4 out of 5 flame-​free heroes


No More Chairs bookcover

No More Chairs
Author: Dan Gill
Illustrator: Susan Gal
Little, Brown Books for Young Readers
1 July 2025
40 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Quiet courage leaves lasting echo.

🪑 4.5 out of 5 welcome chairs


Pencil’s Best Story Ever
Author: Carly Gledhill
Illustrator: Carly Gledhill
Post Wave
29 July 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Art school energy, playground mindset.

🎨 4 out of 5 creative messes


To Catch a Ghost
Author: Rachel Michelle Wilson
Illustrator: Rachel Michelle Wilson
Orchard Books
1 July 2025
40 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Ghost-​hunting manual meets unexpected empathy.

👻 4.25 out of 5 ghost traps

Picture Book Review: 5‑word reviews (The Bear Out There; Don’t Lose Mr. Cuddles; Island Storm; Put Your Shoes On; What Coco Can Do)

Looking for your next picture book crush? These five-​word reviews cut straight to the heart of what makes each new release stand out—no overthinking, just instinct. They’re not deep dives, but quick snapshots of books that surprised, delighted, or stuck with me for one reason or another.

Let’s see which ones grab you too!


The Bear Out There
Author: Jess Hannigan
Illustrator: Jess Hannigan
Quill Tree Books
29 April 2025
48 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Fearless narrator, hilariously unreliable host.

✨ 4.25 out of 5 lights in the darkness


Don’t Lose Mr. Cuddles
Author: Dev Petty
Illustrator: Mike Boldt
Doubleday Books for Young Readers
6 May 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Emotional wreckage meets feline truce.

🎾 4.25 out of 5 squeaky tennis balls


Island Storm
Author: Brian Floca
Illustrator: Sydney Smith
Neal Porter Books
22 July 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Two hearts brave a tempest.

🌧️ 4.5 out of 5 drenched rain slickers


Put Your Shoes On
Author: Polly Dunbar
Illustrator: Polly Dunbar
Candlewick
17 June 2025
40 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Inner worlds resist outer orders.

🐛 4 out of 5 cool caterpillars


What Coco Can Do
Author: Maribeth Boelts
Illustrator: Stephanie Laberis
Candlewick
1 April 2025
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Comfort wears a wagging tail.

🐾 4.25 out of 5 paw prints

Picture Book Review: Where Are You, Brontë? by Tomie dePaola, illustrated by Barbara McClintock

Author: Tomie dePaola
Illustrator: Barbara McClintock
Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers
6 May 2025
48 pages

This month’s PB review is by Ryan G. Van Cleave (Owner/​Operator of Only Picture Book) and freelance author/​illustrator Kelly Light.

–Ryan’s Review of the Writing–

Tomie dePaola’s final text is a quiet, tender farewell from one of picture books’ greats. In a simple, sincere, and exquisitely spare text, dePaola reflects on his years with his beloved dog, Brontë, from her arrival as a puppy to the gentle ache of her absence and the solace of memory.

This is a book of deep feeling, told plainly. The repetition of the title phrase, “Where are you, Brontë?,” becomes a lyrical heartbeat through the pages, an emotional throughline that brings together the past and present. Each scene (such as Brontë sleeping in her crate, bringing toys to the studio, adapting to blindness) is rendered in emotionally rich but unembellished language. The restraint is part of what gives this story its power, but the soft art helps accentuate things. I’ll Kelly explain the what, how and why about that more fully.

There’s no high concept here or big plot twist–just the pure, loving recollection of a life lived beside a treasured companion. For this reader, that’s enough. Honestly, it’s more than enough because it’s real and it speaks to the kind of bond that transforms us. Essentially what begins as a personal story becomes a sweet universal one.

Parents and educators may find this a meaningful way to talk with children about aging, grief, and remembrance. While the emotional tone skews gentle and accepting, this is a book that doesn’t shy away from sadness. And yet, it leaves us with light: “still with me, in my heart forever.” A poignant coda from a master storyteller.

4.75 out of 5 pencils

–Kelly’s Review of the Illustrations–

Barbara McClintock’s illustrations for Where Are You, Brontë? are a tender, visual homage to two beloved figures: the late Tomie dePaola and Brontë, his adored dog. McClintock, herself a master of illustration, steps into a gentler, simplified style reminiscent of dePaola’s, adopting his soft, warm palette with grace and restraint. The result is not imitation, but —one artist allowing herself to be guided by the work of another to create a beautiful tribute.

Having had the rare gift of meeting both Tomie and Brontë, I can say McClintock has captured them perfectly. Tomie’s home—his real New Hampshire haven—is depicted with accuracy, charm, and the art and beauty that surrounded him. The house becomes more than a setting; it is a memory preserved. The carefully placed aqua throughout the book made me smile, evoking memories of his beautiful home.

And then there is Brontë: loyal, slightly mischievous, and always close to Tomie’s side. The story’s simple quest—searching for the missing Brontë—gives McClintock the framework to wander through moments of shared life, letting us see the bond between man and dog, artist and muse. The illustrations never overreach. Like Tomie’s own work, they are deceptively simple, characterized by clear lines, soft textures, and a palette washed in affection. McClintock’s work is typically characterized by the elegant, weighted lines of classic illustration from a much earlier era. Her restraint here proves that sometimes less can be more. DePaola was an illustrator who distilled shapes and lines to their essence, and here, that flows through McClintock’s hand.

McClintock’s reverence for dePaola is palpable, but so is her confidence. She is not trying to be Tomie—she is honoring him. The result is a book that feels like sitting in a sun-​warmed chair, paging through memories that are tender, funny, and full of quiet grace.

Where Are You, Bronte? is not just a tribute. It is a reunion, for fans, for those of us who knew the joy of Tomie and Brontë in real life and most importantly for young readers.

4.75 out of 5 colored pencils


Kelly Light lives in Amherst, MA but grew up down the shore in New Jersey surrounded by giant pink dinosaurs, cotton candy colors, and Skee-​Ball sounds. She was schooled on Saturday-​morning cartoons and Sunday funny pages. She picked up a pencil, started drawing, and never stopped.

Kelly is the author/​illustrator of the Louise series. Louise Loves Art and Louise and Andie, The Art of Friendship are the first two picture books in the series. Louise Loves Bake Sales and Louise and The Class Pet are the first readers in HarperCollins’ I Can Read program.

Kelly has also illustrated Elvis and the Underdogs and Elvis and the Underdogs: Secrets, Secret Service, and Room Service by Jenny Lee, and The Quirks series by Erin Soderberg, as well as the upcoming 2026 picture book release written by author Samantha Berger, Corny, with Henry Holt & Co.

Website: www.kellylight.com